Changes are coming to the Stephen P. Clark Deathstar very soon.
Charter reform: the latest issue du jour. Term limits, easier citizen petitions, new at large districts - these are some of the possible changes facing voters in May, and depending on the details theycould be revolutionary or they could be useless. Mayoral candidates like Commissioner Carlos Gimenez and others on the County Commission are trying to advance sweeping changes to county government. Kudos to them for trying, but without considering sweeping changes to transportation planning and funding, charter reform will not mean much to the residents of Miami-Dade County.
A truly comprehensive charter reform plan must address the inadequacies of our existing system of transportation planning and governance. Multiple overlapping and competing agencies are responsible for planning and financing roads, highways, and transit, with no coordinated, unified vision. Transit capacity is not being expanded, while roadway congestion cost Miami-Dade County residents $3.2 billion in 2009 according to the Texas Transportation Institute “National Congestion Report.”
Among the policy changes advocated by folks like Commissioner Gimenez is a change to county UDB expansion policy – making it more difficult to expand the urban development boundary, as listed in his ‘Blueprint for Charter Reform’. (Gimenez clarified his position at a Latin Builders Association luncheon last week saying he would not rule out moving the line). While Gimenez’ position on the UDB is in flux, one thing is clear: holding the UDB and encouraging infill development must be coordinated with expanded premium transit options within the urban service area. The challenges presented by growth management are intimately tied to local transit options: the two cannot be disconnected.
Voters in 2002 saw the need for the creation of a premium transit network, and passed the visionary People’s Transportation Plan and ½ cent sales tax, mandating the creation of a Citizens Independent Transportation Trust to oversee the tax and act as stewards of the PTP. Though the CITT was created, it was never truly independent, and the plan remains an unfulfilled mandate.
Charter reform is one of our best opportunities to finally take control of our transportation future – through the creation of an independent authority responsible for all transportation planning and expansion in Miami-Dade County. Led by an elected executive transportation professional, the authority would be responsible for setting policy and implementing a plan that works for allcitizens of Miami-Dade County – transit users, cyclists, pedestrians and motorists alike.
With gas prices certain to continue their upward rise, Mayoral candidates like Commissioner Gimenez need to be bold in addressing the imbalance of transportation options in this community. They may want to start by looking at charter reform as part of the answer.
2 Responses to Charter Reform Debate Ignores Transportation
Leave a Reply
Planetizen: The Urban Planning, Design, and Development Network- Turning an Eye on Big Brother June 17, 2013Ever wonder just how many prying eyes are watching you as you amble down a city street? A new app seeks to develop a comprehensive catalog of Big Brother's presence by documenting the locations of security cameras covering a city's public spaces. […]
- Bike Lobby Flexes Its Muscles June 17, 2013Did you chuckle when the WSJ's Dorothy Rabinowitz said "the bike lobby is an all-powerful enterprise”? Well, "[t]he bicycle lobby is real," say Byron Tau and Caitlin Emma, who explore the increasing clout of those fighting for bike infrastructure. […]
- Discovery of 'Lost Recipe' for Ancient Concrete Provides Foundation for Future Cities June 17, 2013Portland cement doesn't come close to matching the resiliency of the concrete created by ancient Romans. After years of research, scientists believe they've unravelled the ingredients and production techniques that made Roman concrete so superior. […]
- Where’s the Heat Going? Global Warming Lull Befuddles Scientists June 17, 2013Despite record levels of greenhouse gas emissions, global surface temperatures have risen at a much slower rate over the past 15 years than the 20 years prior. Scientists are struggling to explain a warming plateau. […]
- Iowa Gov. Rules Out Taxes, Fees, and Tolls to Fund Transportation Projects June 17, 2013To the chagrin of many state legislators, Gov. Terry Branstad opposes new revenue measures to fund transportation projects, as he believes he is following the wishes of his constituents. Tax cuts, not increases, are on his agenda. […]
- To Compete, Phoenix Must Grow Up, Not Out June 17, 2013As Wellington 'Duke' Reiter notes, for the past several decades Phoenix has shown it expertise in horizontal growth. But, as development heats up again after the Great Recession, he says the city's growth must be managed to increase density. […]
- Elite Citadels: The Global Growth of the Gated City June 17, 2013Gated communities were once confined to specific neighborhoods or suburban areas, but as the global financial sector grows, entire cities are becoming gated enclaves where the 'one per cent' network and drive national policies, says Simon Kuper. […]
- Has Toronto Built Too Much Too Fast? June 17, 2013As Toronto's condo building boom has transformed the city, it's also helped to transform Canada's housing market. There are warning signs, however, that a surplus of housing in the city threatens to destabilize Canada's entire economy. […]
- Chicago's $218 Million Unfinished Basement June 17, 2013Greg Hinz tours the unfinished 'superstation' under Block 37 in the central Loop, built by the Chicago Transit Authority at a cost of $218 million. It would cost an estimated $150 million to complete, a sum that's unlikely to be raised anytime soon. […]
- How Will the Government Manage China's Great Urban Leap? June 17, 2013Ian Johnson explores a pivotal moment in China's development, as the country seeks to migrate 250 million rural residents to cities in the next 12 years. Observers speculate on how a comprehensive urbanization plan will achieve this transition. […]
- Turning an Eye on Big Brother June 17, 2013
Charter reform discussion underway right now at http://www.880thebiz.com/
This seems like an opportune time to address transportation planning and inadequacies in the charter. I suppose it is too late to add anything to the May vote on charter changes, but perhaps writing to Carlos Gimenez, or another commissioner, and asking them to address transportation could be a good start. Perhaps the combination of the recent recall, wrath of voters, and recent negative press Miami-Dade Transit (MDT) has received regarding federal grant payments, will be enough to get the county commission to address the transit problems.
I’ve already written to my commissioner. Perhaps others could do that, as well as having TransitMiami write an open letter the county commission and post it online. Perhaps a better idea would be to turn Norman Braman into an transit advocate and have him finance an effort to get transit reform (I doubt he would because then he might sell less cars). Either way, I say lets take our comments and complaints to the commission and hope they are shaken up enough to listen.